Reaction To Jordan Peterson’s Message To Muslims

Reaction To Jordan Peterson’s Message To Muslims

In a contemporary six-and-a-half minute video message, Jordan Peterson, scientific psychologist and professor emeritus on the College of Toronto, referred to as upon his assumed Muslim target market to make sure adjustments. In particular, he exhorted them to prevent intra-faith Shia-Sunni animosity, prevent hating Jews, to go back to their spiritual roots and to embody the new Abraham Accord.

The tone used to be patronizing, and Peterson’s “name” ignores the bigger political dynamics at play. Peterson expects, as he says, for “Muslims to achieve around the sectarian divide – particularly Shiites. Discover a Sunni pen friend, keep up a correspondence with somebody at the different aspect.” He additionally suggested that, “Sunnis, do the similar after which, perhaps, tentatively, achieve out to a Christian, or heaven forbid, a Jew.”

Within the message, Peterson welcomed his new Muslim fans. However his feedback on sectarian variations, whilst in all probability well-meaning, had been slammed as ill-informed, condescending, and crass via some. He invited a Muslim to construct an “digital machine to deliver other people from the Sunni and Shiite neighborhood in combination,” and that he would put it up for sale. On Fb and Twitter, Muslims shared their perspectives on Peterson’s concepts of Muslim family members. We’ve accrued few responses from some researchers, teachers, and chaplains from social media at the factor:

Reaction To Jordan Peterson’s Message To Muslims

Uthman Badar [PhD Researcher, Australia]

Stay supporting MuslimMatters for the sake of Allah

Alhamdulillah, we are at over 850 supporters. Assist us get to 900 supporters this month. All it takes is a small reward from a reader such as you to stay us going, for simply $2 / month.

The Prophet (SAW) has taught us the most productive of deeds are those who achieved persistently, although they’re small.
Click on right here to strengthen MuslimMatters with a per thirty days donation of $2 per 30 days. Set it and acquire blessings from Allah (swt) for the khayr you might be supporting with out eager about it.

Message to Dr Jordan B Peterson

Re: Message to Muslims

Pricey Jordan,

Uthman Badar, PhD

Uthman Badar, PhD

Your probably trustworthy intent to seek out answers to international issues is admirable, however you’re taking a look within the incorrect position. Your lack of knowledge about trends within the ‘Western civilisation’ that you simply habitually extol is relating to. One thing referred to as ‘secularism’ came about some two centuries in the past. Faith used to be subordinated and relegated to the margins of all this is essential and influential in politics and public lifestyles. The Pope used to be made to retire to the Vatican and transform a footnote to international politics that does little greater than factor now predictable however impotent requires peace…. Muftis and rabbis of officialdom too were hired via secular energy internationally.

This ‘enlightened’ way of living used to be then compelled on the barrel of a gun—as best enlightened people can—in Asia and Africa. All of the states there now are secular too.

Your implicit analysis, then, of prevailing conflicts and issues as a serve as of interfaith clashes is available in naïve (or handy?) lack of awareness of all this. It’s, nonetheless, together with the corresponding prescription, woefully insufficient. Religion does no longer play this sort of vital function on this planet affairs of a Secular Age. Secular ideologies do—manipulating religion when expedient.

However you must know this. Imagine the left-right, conservative-liberal, woke-asleep debates that you simply’re robotically engaged in (and in more and more commercialised style)—when no longer lecturing Muslims and Christians to type themselves out. Are those no longer decidedly secular ‘squabbles’? The ‘tradition’ wars are so-called for a reason why, appropriate?

Imagine as properly primary examples of latest international battle: the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, Russian aggression in Ukraine, Israeli aggression on Gaza, the ‘Struggle on Terror’ that gave us Guantanamo Bay and ISIS. What have any of those to do with interfaith battle? Is the US a Christian theocracy? Or a mundane liberal democracy (with a sprinkling of Christian rhetoric every now and then)? Is Russia an Orthodox theocracy? Or a mundane socialist regime? And so forth.

Likewise, you could presume that Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, or Iran are Islamic regimes, however they don’t seem to be. They’re fashionable secular states with a sprinkling of Islamic rhetoric or embellishment.

The ‘Abraham Accords’ had been signed via ‘Israel’, the UAE, and the United States. Which of those is constituted or pushed via religion? The ‘Jewish state’ constructed on a brutal dispossession of thousands and thousands? The despotic gulf statelet run like a circle of relatives mafia? Or probably the most violent state on this planet, constituted via a ‘wall of separation’ between church and state?  Has that wall fallen down such that the United States is now signing accords on behalf of the ‘Folks of the Ebook’?

You’ll’t have fun secularism at the one hand, after which blame the issues on faith, at the different. What kind of conceptual gymnastics is that?

The truth of the subject is that secularism is the order of the day, most commonly in it liberal iteration. Secular liberal states are probably the most influential actors at the international degree, and, in flip, are essentially answerable for the mess we see on that degree. It’s an outdated secular trope to construe issues as emanating from spiritual battle/hatred and recommend extra interfaith discussion/unity as the answer. This can be a handy depoliticization and dehistorisation of battle achieved to essentialise it as spiritual (or ethnic/cultural). One should be shallow to fall for it, even though.

If dialog is the best way ahead, then, I’m afraid you’ll want extra ‘woke’ pen-pals to type out your secular ideological squabbles. Forestall hating’, get started speaking’ (preferably with much less rhetoric, extra substance). Higher nonetheless, check out that specialize in the true issues of energy in our international and we’d all be higher for it.

Yahya Birt [British-American writer and academic]

Yahya Birt

Yahya Birt

I think just like the circle is whole. JP addressed his substantial “Moslem” fanbase (how he drawls “Muslim”, quite fittingly sounding extra like مظلم “oppressor” than مسلم “trustworthy submitter to God”) without delay for the primary time nowadays, from his new platform on the Day-to-day Twine. Some can not comprise their pleasure: see the remark segment beneath his video. One Muslim man calls Peterson “my virtual father”.

Peterson calls on his “Moslem” fans to position apart their (assumed, presumed) enmity against Christians and Jews particularly within the wake of the Emirati-Israel-US-sponsored Abrahamic Accords of 2020. It’s your inveterate anti-Semitism you “Moslems” should surrender, Peterson avers (eliding opposition to violent settler colonialism and the dispossession of the Palestinian other people). The actual enemy is your ego, and the Luciferian woke neo-Marxist brigade, 20{7f51ac40f6214d9cc962c00cd1c80ca1639aba1a1e3c5bebbfbfbe6307cdff68} of whom are irredeemable.

If I shut my eyes I may have been paying attention to Sheikh Hamza albeit with out his mellifluous fusha, which is certainly the purpose.

The circle is whole. The Venn diagram of the alt-right, the akh-right, the Zionists, the evangelicals, the neo-traditionalists and their Republican, Israeli and Emirati sponsors has now emerged into one.

Allahumma, save us from this heartless state-sponsored spiritual nationalism, whose true father is Firawn/Pharaoh quite than Musa/Moses who liberated his other people from slavery and oppression. Amin.

Ahmed Deeb

Imam Ahmed Deeb

However his doable genuineness, this used to be embarrassingly condescending and out of pocket. It felt like paying attention to a sermon that Islamophobes and maximum media retailers love to provide: “Whats up Muslims, why aren’t you condemning violence extra? Why aren’t you attaining around the aisle extra? Don’t you already know you have got the capability for peace similar to us?”

All of the whilst by no means in point of fact giving Muslims the chance to talk, and not amplifying the unique voices that do.

To cut back our issues to sectarian battle after which let us know—in probably the most superficial means—the best way to get to the bottom of them is at highest probably the most hilarious display of naïveté I’ve ever observed from a self-proclaimed trustworthy public highbrow.

One rational clarification I will bring to mind: now that he’s joined a notoriously appropriate wing media corporate (the twine), perhaps he feels he has to begin appearing some alliance to their narratives via parroting the typical tropes, essential of which within the years of Trump’s reign used to be how divided, bad, internally corrupt, and adversarial the “Muslim international” is. Muslims are, we’re advised, a number of hypocrites not able to observe the Prophetic teachings they love to speak about such a lot, teachings which after all are highest understood via other people like him or heretics they make a selection to platform.

It’s movies like this that spotlight the inconsistencies of his messaging and forged doubt upon his declare to trustworthy reality in quest of and fellowship construction.

No quantity of “there’s reality to what he’s pronouncing right here” can justify this sort of tone-deaf video. I say that as somebody who would need him and everybody else steerage and get in touch with to the similar form of highbrow collaboration he claims to champion.

(I’ve) such a lot of extra ideas in this, and don’t even know the place to start out. If I’ve time, I’ll do a fuller breakdown of his issues right here and what they spotlight. I’m nonetheless processing it.

Right here’s my non-public takeaway mirrored image to this point: what emboldened him to with a bit of luck be this condescending against what he himself admits is considered one of his maximum dependable fan bases?

Consider any superstar public highbrow being brazen sufficient to mention to any in their dependable fan bases the identical of: “as somebody who has admitted he is aware of little to not anything about your religion and your other people’s realities, let me advise you guys, thru your individual religion that I don’t know a lot about, on the way you must get your act in combination.” Any individual who would check out can be on the very least publicly corrected. As a substitute, Jordan will get feedback from Muslims pronouncing, “you might be 100{7f51ac40f6214d9cc962c00cd1c80ca1639aba1a1e3c5bebbfbfbe6307cdff68} appropriate about us, we adore you!”

The easy solution is us. We embolden those other people via hanging our uncritical hopes for a faith-driven life within the fingers of people who are obviously nonetheless going thru their very own messy trips of exploration. We embolden those other people via our lack of confidence, and we deal with that lack of confidence among our personal other people thru our endured half-baked efforts in in point of fact instructing them about our worldviews.

This video is an confirmation of 2 constant realities:  (1) Folks nonetheless imagine us and our other people totally vulnerable, and short of saviours from outdoor our neighborhood (no marvel there). (2) We’re obviously no longer succeeding within the public highbrow sphere when other people like him are saviours for younger Muslims and their religion.

We’ve but to comprehend the duty handy and feature little grip on correct priorities after we spend extra time arguing with each and every different in our crew assume bubbles right here than to paintings tougher against correctly generating the infrastructure—institutionally and individually—that permits us to have interaction other people like him on the perfect point. On the very least giving our younger other people self belief not to have such blind agree with in other people like Peterson.

As Muslims, we are not any strangers to defeat or embarrassment. But as individuals who consider we hang the Reality, is our Ummatic reaction—as arguably probably the most privileged Muslim neighborhood on this planet in training and economics—consultant of our legacy of conquer the sort of defeat?

So sure, there’s without a doubt a grain of reality to what he stated, and if we’re uninterested in listening to such bigotry-laced, condescending half-truths, we may do ourselves a favour to re-prioritize our energies.

“A believer does no longer humiliate himself.” -Prophet Muhammad

Allahu A’lam. I’ll let my way more certified colleagues and pals who’re well known to you all proportion their ideas, which I do know can be insightful and piercing.

Sharif Abu Laith [Researcher, Speaker and Commentator]

Sharif Abu Laith

Sharif Abu Laith

Dr Jordan B Peterson, I admire that you’ve got invited Muslims onto your display and sincerely engaged them to grasp Islam. Then again, your newest video titled “Message to Muslims” frankly comes throughout as patronising and ignorant in regards to the fresh standing of the Muslim international. The issue isn’t battle between or inside religions. The battle exists because of colonial and neo-colonial insurance policies that experience had an enduring have an effect on at the Muslim international.

Let me provide you with a couple of examples. Zionism used to be a political motion that began within the U.Ok., calling for a native land for the Jews. Thirty one years after Britain occupied Palestine in 1917, they helped established a Zionist entity that resulted within the compelled expulsion of about 1 million Palestinians. Israel then endured to increase its profession of Palestine territory, inflicting resentment, anger and destruction of the way of living of the unique population.

On the identical time, we all know that it wasn’t just a subject of Israel being based (via the West) after the British occupied the area, however Western international locations, particularly The united states, dedicated to supplying billions of bucks to the Israeli state (within the type of navy help) whilst turning a blind eye to the killings and oppression of Palestinians via Israel.

So why is there anger? Now not as a result of some drawback inside, however a broader drawback with colonialism and the ongoing Western strengthen for regimes like Israel whilst turning a blind eye to their oppressive movements and killings of innocents.

In a similar fashion, we see that Western states helped create the present political regimes that are living within the Muslim international. A very simple instance is the Egyptian regime, which receives navy help for keeping up a military-business dictatorship, thus no longer permitting the folks to select the kind of governance they would like. The Egyptian navy no longer best controls politics, but in addition the financial system, media or even training. As such, any person stuck criticising the army and its management faces imprisonment, torture or even demise. To reiterate, it is a navy regime that has shut ties with Western states as observed thru navy help and financial ties.

And those identical regimes would stoke sectarian and spiritual battle, just like the false flag assaults on Coptic church buildings in Egypt in 2011 to protected their authority via distracting the folks clear of their egregious crimes of the regime and makes an attempt to color any Islamic opposition as doable threats to minority populations.

There are such a lot of different examples, however one final one is the present sectarianism that plagues Iraq. It essentially resulted from the West’s invasion of Iraq in 2002 and the consequent fallout that noticed sectarian militias, a few of whom had been without delay supported via Western occupying forces, to police different sects and spaces.

The purpose is that one can not whitewash Western states and their political agendas inside the Muslim international, bearing in mind their interventions have without delay contributed to the present turmoil inside the Muslim international. And as we all know, this time table is pushed via in large part capitalist pursuits.

If then you need to look balance on this planet and foster actual engagement of Muslims, my request to you is to introspectively have a look at Western states’ insurance policies towards the Muslim international, no longer best during the last 130 years or so but in addition the present political interference we see nowadays. It’s best via enticing on this fair introspection and conserving tough states like The united states to account for his or her movements within the Muslim international are we able to foster higher working out on either side.

Samir Hussain [Researcher and teacher trained in Islamic Sciences]

Ustad Samir Hussain

Ustad Samir Hussain

Dr. Jordan Peterson simply posted a ‘Message for Muslims’ on YouTube. I first spoke about how problematic it’s for Muslims to blindly practice JP in spiritual discourse a few years in the past, and I’m sounding the alarm once more, simply tougher this time.

Some notes:

1) We stated that. On his message on team spirit and dealing in combination and letting Islam display in our movements, a few of our most sensible students were pronouncing the similar factor he stated for years. I train the similar ethos in my categories. However I’m wondering what number of people will pay attention now best as a result of their Sheikh JP stated it. Until you’ve been underneath a rock, students like Sh. Amin Kholwadia & Sh. Abdul Hakim Murad and all the ones students curious about anti-sectarian or interfaith discussion were pronouncing the similar factor.

2) Reductive. JP’s message is intentionally (or ignorantly) reductive and condescending. He omits the truth that a lot of our sectarianism has political roots. You’ll attempt to advertise Muslim team spirit all you need, however you’re preventing an uphill struggle towards Saudi, Emirati (whose propaganda JP appears to be falling for) and Iranian petrodollars.

The similar is going for having sure interactions with Christians and Jews. We’d cherish to do so, however that exhortation is Orientalist and racist (as analysis into our historical past assists in keeping demonstrating). It’s very exhausting for Muslims to assume undoubtedly of those faiths when their contributors are drone bombing Muslim international locations, oppressing Palestinians, or when the far-right and conservative Christians are preaching ‘Muslim bans’ and Islamophobia. JP quotes the Abraham Accords, as a result of it appears to be just right to Jews (which now we have many times achieved right through our historical past) we need to acquiesce to the crimes of Israel.

As I highlighted a few years in the past, no longer best is theology a vulnerable level, however his take hold of of geopolitics could also be dreadfully deficient. In case you imagine him an expert, you’re going to be misled. He’s a scientific psychologist, no longer a theologian, exegete or perhaps a thinker.

3)Misrepresentaton coming. It kind of feels that each one those that sought after JP to be extra pro-Muslim were given their want. However now I’m expecting extra statement via JP on Islamic theology and tafsir. Christians have already been important of JP for his misrepresentations of Christian theology and biblical exegesis. We must be expecting identical misrepresentation.

4) We’ve our personal thinkers. Finally, JP merits credit score for ‘opening up’ and normalizing conservative, spiritual discourse in mild of the entire insanity we’re seeing from exhausting liberals. He additionally merits credit score for being sympathetic to Islam and Muslims in mild of the novel Islamophobia of many well-liked on-line atheists and pseudo-intellectuals. It will be great to look certified Muslim students proceeding to have interaction him.

Younger Muslims, I as soon as once more provide you with a warning once more from taking this particular person as an expert and bearing in mind him some type of standout, towering highbrow determine. He’s no longer. He’s reasonably moderate for an highbrow, and the issue is that lots of his fans (and every now and then it sort of feels he himself) imagine him to be above moderate or of a particularly elite point.

Turn into extra accustomed to your individual high-level students and extra fluent on your personal highbrow custom. There’s a lot (to worth and be told) there.

Leave a Reply